Jyoti Basu dies, remembered by US media and BBC


Jyoti_basu Jyoti Basu died today after prolonged illness in his hometown, Calcutta (now Kolkata). His death is being reported by not just by Indian newspapers but also by the New York Times, Wall Street Journal and the BBC.

An Associated Press report published in the Journal says:

Veteran communist leader Jyoti Basu, who in 1996 came close to becoming India's prime minister, died Sunday after a prolonged illness, a party spokesman said. He was 96.

Mr. Basu became chief minister of West Bengal state in 1977 and served for 23 years, making him the longest-serving chief minister in India's political history. In 1996, a group of parties asked Mr. Basu to lead a coalition government in New Delhi. However, the communist party declined, saying it didn't want to be part of a government in which it didn't have a majority. Mr. Basu later described that decision as a "historic blunder."

The New York Times looks back on his political career :

Jyoti Basu, a powerful leftist leader who dominated politics in the state of West Bengal for more than two decades and nearly became India’s first Communist prime minister, died in Calcutta on Sunday. He was 95.

Continue Reading

Caviar and fine wine for communist leaders of Bengal

Jyoti-basu-april16

Asim_dasgupta_april16

The former Economist editor Bill Emmott met the veteran Communist Party of India (Marxist) leader Jyoti Basu, who was then chief minister of West Bengal, and his party colleague, Asim Dasgupta, who is still the state's finance minister. Emmott describes their meeting in his book, Rivals: How The Power Struggle Between China, India and Japan, published last year. He writes:

A very generous and hospitable local businesman had laid on a dinner for us at his home, and had kindly invited the two politicians. In Kolkata, poverty is highly visible right on the streets, and so the contrast of gliding past beggars and street dwellers to visit a comfortable home is always disconcerting, at least for an outsider.

The politicians underlined the contradictions even more. Ever since 1977, West Bengal politics has been dominated by none other than the Communist Party of India (Marxist), and Mr Basu was the chief minister for 23 years from then until his retirement in 2000.

Our host's table was excellent: the first course essentially consisted of caviar, accompanied by a fine Puligny-Montrachet. The communist politicians were not disconcerted at all. They seemed to enjoy the hospitality, especially the caviar.

Yes, it is a cheap point. Communist politicians everywhere have to sup with capitalists, and "champagne socialist" is a term familiar in London, too.

But the CPI(M) in general, and the government of West Bengal in particular, is a rich source of paradox.

The communists hindered national development while trying to develop their own state of West Bengal, says Emmott.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh could not go against their wishes because his Congress coalition government depended on their support. Finally the communists withdrew their support in protest against the nuclear agreement he signed with President George Bush, but by then he was approaching the end of his term.

Polling begins today to elect a new government.

Continue Reading

Calcutta goes to the polls

The world’s longest-ruling communist government looks likely to be returned to power for another five years in West Bengal. They have been in power for 29 years now — and it looks like there’s no reversing the red tide for now. As a Reuter’s report said: “Communists draw middle-class vote in West Bengal”.

Elections are being held over five days — today was only the third day — other parts of the state will go to the polls on May 2 and 8. But Reuters is already saying the communist-led Left Front coalition of leftist parties is looking forward to a seventh straight term in office in this eastern Indian state of 80 million people. Nearly 50 million are voters and the turnout was as high as 80 per cent on the first two days. I am sure the polling stations saw the same large crowds today when 12 million people were eligible to vote in Calcutta and two neighbouring districts for 76 seats in the 294-seat state assembly.

One reason for such a high turnout must be that people believe in exercising their right to vote.

But though the state has been voting for the communists for such a long time, it does not mean everybody is a communist. There are people who are not seriously interested in politics at all. But many of them may vote for the communists because they have ensured law and order.

And people respect Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, the gentlemanly, culturally inclined Communist Party of India (Marxist) leader with a spotless reputation who became chief minister of West Bengal in 2001.

He is a breath of fresh air after Jyoti Basu, the former Marxist chief minister.

Basu, who was chief minister from 1977 to 2001, is one of those leftist aristocrats. He was accepted as a leader, I suspect, partly because he belonged to the communist party in Britain when he went to study law there. Those colonial/Western connections count even among the communists in India. He was born well, married well, and his son did well under his rule even if the rest of the state did not.

West Bengal fell behind other states during the long rule of Basu. But the communists were far better organised than the other parties. They did good work in the villages and controlled the administrative machinery in the state.

Still, they faced a serious challenge in  2001 from a breakaway faction of the Congress party — which was out of power then but now runs the federal government in Delhi.

The communists still won the 2001 elections. That was the last time the state police forces, controlled by the communist state government, guarded the polling booths.

This time federal police forces have been deployed for a fairer election.

But this is an election the communists are expected to win fair and square. Because the new chief has done good work for the state.

Calcutta boasts new shopping malls, new apartment complexes. There are new jobs and investments. Someone visiting Calcutta for the first time may see it is a dusty overcrowded city with little remarkable about it. But we who were born and raised in Calcutta know how much it has changed since the bad old days of Jyoti Basu. That in itself deserves a vote of thanks.

Polls in India: Communists set to keep Calcutta

The world’s longest serving elected communist government looks set to return to power again and complete 30 years in office next year.

The communist administration in Calcutta (Kolkata), the capital of the Indian state of West Bengal, faces no real challenge in the state assembly elections which began in four of India’s 29 states and one of the six Union Territories yesterday.  Assam, Kerala, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal will all be electing new state governments and the Union Territory of Pondicherry a new local administration. The results won’t be known until mid-May because the elections are being staggered over several days and will continue till next month.

Only three of West Bengal’s 19 districts went to the polls yesterday but the result is already a foregone conclusion. The communists are heading for a landslide, reported the Rediffusion website and the Hindu newspaper. And that is the election that seems to be making the most headlines. The only Indian election news on the BBC News’ South Asia website at the moment is devoted to West Bengal and for a very good reason. “West Bengal is governed by the world’s longest-running elected Communist administration,” it said. The communists have won every election in West Bengal since 1977.

It is a remarkable record. It is true that the ruling political parties in the region where I now live have been in power even longer. Umno has been in power in Malaysia since 1957 and the People’s Action Party in Singapore since 1959. But they hold power at the national level. They run the country and can change the laws and electoral districts in their favour. The PAP government in predominantly Chinese Singapore introduced Group Representation Constituencies — multi-member wards — to represent the minorities — Malays, Indians, Eurasians — but the opposition says it makes it harder for them to find enough candidates to contest all the seats in parliament.

The communists in West Bengal have no such power. Election laws can be amended only by the federal parliament in New Delhi, which also has an independent Election Commission to oversee national and state elections. The communists and the Election Commission are frequently at loggerheads. Since the local administration, including the state police force, is controlled by the communist state government, the Election Commission has brought in federal police forces to guard election booths. There has been jiggery pokery in the past with the state police and local officials turning a blind eye to communist irregularities at the hustings. But such irregularities only increased the margin of communist victories. The majority voted for the communists anyway.

Exit polls this time point to the communists winning between 233 and 243 seats in the 294-seat state assembly, reported the Hindu newspaper.

What lies behind their amazing popularity? West Bengal fell behind several other states under communist rule, especially when Jyoti Basu was chief minister from 1977 to 2000. Age might have been one reason why he stepped down then — he will be celebrating his 92nd birthday on July 8 this year — but another reason could have been his growing unpopularity. Questions used to be asked about the remarkable rise of his son as an industrialist. But while industries moved out of West Bengal during Basu’s rule, the communists did good work in the villages, redistributing land, bringing power and electricity. And there was no communal violence. Hindus and Muslims lived peacefully together.

There was graft and corruption, as in every other state, and fighting between political parties.

But the communists somehow seemed cleaner than the other political parties. Voters remembered the violence and infighting when Congress — now in power in Delhi — last ruled the state in the 1970s. Some of the Congress leaders in the state were seen as corrupt and they fought among themselves, never posing a serious challenge to the communists. The Hindu nationalists who came to power in Delhi in 1998 and ruled the country till they lost the 2004 elections never made any headway in West Bengal.

The only threat to the communists came from a breakaway faction of the Congress which joined hands with the Hindu nationalists, but it was too militant and disorganised to be effective for very long. And now the communists are more popular than ever under the new chief minister, Buddhadeb Bhattacharya.

Bhattacharya, who succeeded Basu as his handpicked successor in 2000, is a clean, middle-class, culturally inclined Bengali gentleman whose only flaw is railing frequently against George W Bush and America. That’s natural perhaps for a leader of the Communist Party of India (Marxist). But he sounds awfully naive sometimes. However, he has been wooing investors and West Bengal is making progress again.

The three West Bengal districts which went to the polls yesterday are home to another group of communists, the more violent Maoists who believe in armed struggle and called a poll boycott this time as well. (Yes, India unlike China still has diehard followers of Chairman Mao.) But people want peace, not violence. And, despite the Maoists’ poll boycott call, 70 per cent voted.

Elections in West Bengal are being held over five days, on April 17, April 22, April 27, May 2 and May 8, and the votes will be counted on May 11.

In Calcutta the campaigning this time is more peaceful and low-key. I thought that unusual given the Bengalis’ love for culture, politics and any kind of excitement. But they don’t have a choice. The Election Commission has banned political graffiti, banners and posters. Soutik Biswas has a colourful feature on “Calcutta’s colourless campaign” on the BBC website. It is hurting the graffiti artists, but I am glad they cannot go about defacing the walls of people’s homes. Politicians, however, have found ways to get around the ban. A Muslim candidate has hired horses and decorated them with party banners to campaign in the suburbs!

%d bloggers like this: